• Pinterest
  • Print
  • Save
  • Facebook
  • Email

Broken Heart Cookies

  • Prep 10 min
  • Total 40 min
  • Servings 20
  • Pinterest
  • Print
  • Save
  • Facebook
  • Email

These cookies look like broken conversation heart candies -- but the fun part is that you add the sentiment! Make it "MEH" or "NO WAY" or "WHATEVER" ... or, whatever! MORE + LESS -

Eden Passante
December 24, 2014



package Betty Crocker™ sugar cookie mix
egg (per package directions)
stick (1/2 cup) butter (per package directions)


4 1/2
cups powdered sugar
tablespoons meringue powder
tablespoons warm water (more or less, depending on consistency)
Pastels food colors for cookies + red for writing, or as desired


Hide Images
  • 1
    Make cookie dough as directed on package. Roll out dough and cut into heart shapes with a cookie cutter. With a sharp knife, cut a crack into each heart to look like a broken heart. Bake as directed on package, until edges are golden brown, about 8 - 10 minutes.
  • 2
    Remove from oven and reshape gently, if needed. (Tip: You can use your cookie cutter to reshape the warm cookies.) Allow to cool completely.
  • 3
    Meanwhile, make the frosting. In a stand mixer with a paddle attachment, add powdered sugar and meringue powder to mixer bowl. On medium speed, add 1 tablespoon of water at a time until desired consistency is achieved. You want the frosting to be thin enough to melt within the outline of the cookie, but not so thin that it runs over the edges. If too thick, add warm water a teaspoon at a time to thin. If too thin, add powdered sugar to thicken.
  • 4
    Divide the frosting into plastic food bags. Add food coloring to each bag as desired. For the look of conversation heart candy, use pink, lavender, white and yellow plus red for the writing. Using a piping bag and small circle tips, frost the cookies. Allow to set and then use the red to write sentiments on the cookies.
  • 5
    Ideas for anti-Valentine's Day sentiments: Nah, No Way, Whatever, Single Ladies, Meh ... or whatever your heart dreams up!

Nutrition Information

No nutrition information available for this recipe
More About This Recipe
Like conversation heart cookies, but you get to make up the sayings! Go ahead ... let it all out!

Some say Valentine's Day is just for the lovers, but why can't the single people have some fun too?

We've all been there. Nothing helps heal a broken heart or being single on the biggest love day of the year like sweets.

So on that note, we're mixing things up a bit with these Broken Heart Cookies, complete with messages that you write yourself. 

These cookies will bring a smile to your face and a maybe even few giggles from your friends. Perfect for co-workers, and if you get the nerve to send them to an ex, these delicious bites of sarcasm are easy to make and may even help you get over it. Be careful, though – they're  tasty and might get you a date or two despite yourself!

Here's the how-to:

Whip up a batch of Betty Crocker sugar cookies. Follow the directions on the back of the bag.

Roll the dough out.

Cut heart shapes with a cookie cutter.

Then make a little crack halfway down the heart with a sharp knife.

Bake the cookies until the edges are golden brown, about 8-10 minutes.

After removing them from the oven, and while they are still hot, reshape a bit if necessary. Allow to cool.

Divide the frosting into separate plastic food bags and add food coloring to each. If you want them to look like conversation heart candy, make the colors yellow, pink, lavender and white. Don't forget red, too, for the writing!

Carefully frost each cookie and allow frosting to set before writing on each.

Then use red icing to write your sentiments. Think opposite of the conversation heart candies – stuff like:

Meh Single Ladies Nah Whatever No Way

...or any little pearl of sarcastic wisdom you want to get off your chest!

These are just a whole lot of playful fun. So go ahead and enjoy Valentine's Day ... your way!

© 2017 ®/TM General Mills All Rights Reserved