More About This Recipe
Cute as a button. A peppermint patty button!
When I took my first bite of these chocolate cut-out cookies with a hint of peppermint, I just about cried at the deliciousness. After decorating them with their little smiles, I just about cried from the cuteness. Great. How can I eat them now? With them looking at me all happy?
This is my new go-to chocolate cut out cookie. It's even made from chocolate cake mix, which means it’s super easy to mix up. You don’t have to add the peppermint extract, and I’ll likely skip it for the other eleven months of the year, but it does add a lovely seasonal flavor.
Don’t fear the fondant, either. It’s surprisingly easy to work with when you use store-bought (found in the craft store). And the decoration on these cuties is very simple.
To make the chocolate cut-out cookies, mix together Betty Crocker chocolate cake mix with a stick of softened butter, one egg, a teaspoon of vanilla extract and half a teaspoon of peppermint extract or flavoring. Mix until a dough forms. Cover the dough and refrigerate for two hours.
On a floured surface, roll the dough about 1/8-inch thick. A thinner dough helps limit spreading, and at 1/8-inch, my cookies baked well and held their shape perfectly. Just be sure to not roll your dough too thick. Cut out your circles. The cookie cutter shown here is 2 1/4-inches in diameter, but you can use any circle that’s comparable in size.
Place the circles on a baking tray lined with parchment paper and bake until set and the edges are firm. Let the cookies cool completely.
Meanwhile, prepare the frosting and fondant.
To make the frosting, stir 1/2-teaspoon of peppermint extract or flavoring into a can of Betty Crocker vanilla frosting. Cover and set aside.
While we’re here with the frosting: If you skip the fondant decoration, you can spread the frosting instead and then sprinkle with the tops with crushed candy canes for a bit of chocolate mint heaven.
To prepare the fondant, take a chunk of store-bought white fondant and briefly knead it. Roll it out on a surface dusted with confectioner’s sugarto about 1/4-inch thick.
Move the fondant frequently when rolling so it doesn’t stick to the counter. The fondant should be easy to handle, not sticky and difficult. If the fondant is giving you any trouble at all, dust your hands and the fondant with confectioner’s sugar. Cut out circles using the same cookie cutter you used for the cookies. Place the circles on a baking tray lined with wax or parchment paper. Cover with a piece of wax paper until your chocolate cookies are ready to decorate.
To prepare the red fondant, start with a smaller piece of fondant (enough to fit in the palm of your hand). Add a few drops of red food coloring and knead very well, adding more drops of food coloring until the desired shade is reached.
Warning: If you don't use gloves, your hands will be stained for a day or two, so don’t knead red coloring into fondant the day before that hand modeling shoot.
Adding food coloring to fondant can make it even stickier, so dust your hands with confectioner’s sugar if you need to, or let the fondant rest at room temperature uncovered for 15 minutes to stiffen a bit.
Roll the red fondant out on a piece of wax paper. It will help you limit the use of confectioner’s sugar on the red surface of the fondant. But go ahead and use a light dusting of confectioner’s sugar if needed.
Cut strips of fondant 1/2-inch thick with the pizza roller. Cut crosswise with the pizza roller to form rectangles about 1/2-inch by 3/8-inch.
To assemble your cookies, spread a thin layer of the peppermint frosting on the center of a cookie, stopping short of the edges. Place a white fondant circle on top and smooth with your fingers.
Gently smush and smooth red stripes around the edge of the white fondant. Use small dabs of water to adhere the red stripes as needed.
When you’ve decorated the cookies with fondant, if you like, draw smiley faces with the black edible writer. Or, any face! Look at this gloomy Gus. And his pal there seems shocked at his own minty freshness.
But whether gloomy and shocked, or all smiley and happy, these chocolate peppermint cookies are adorable. And did I mention delicious?